Even the agency’s successes have turned out to be failures, says Tim Weiner, the author of "Legacy of Ashes". This is one of the most detailed & well researched book about the agency's failures & short coming. At a time when the CIA is on trial, at least in the public opinion, for the " harsh interrogation techniques" this book is a must read.
read more | digg story
Showing posts with label cia. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cia. Show all posts
Saturday, April 25, 2009
Former CIA Bob Baer On Bill Maher:" Torture Doesn't Work "
This interview of Bob Baer on Bill Maher, last night, is one of the best argument against torture. First and foremost, it is a crime as defined by the Geneva Convention. Second it doesn't bring any accurate information.Baer says that when you are submitted to it,you end up saying whatever your torturer wants to hear.So it is wrong & ineffective.
read more | digg story
read more | digg story
Labels:
bill maher,
bob baer,
cia,
top page digg,
torture,
written by Gilbert Mercier
Sunday, April 19, 2009
Obama's Decision:" Worse Than a Crime, It's a Mistake"
This 200 years old French political saying was 1st used in the case of the Duc D'Enghien. The Duc was plotting to assassinate Napoleon, he was caught and executed on Napoleon's orders. The execution had the effect to energize Napoleon's opposition within the French aristocracy.
The case of President Obama refusing to prosecute the CIA agents for torture is drastically different in appearance but has, as a matter of fact, quite a lot of political similarities.
There is a lack of logic to it from a legal stand point, and further it is a political disaster in the making.
First, if you are not going to prosecute the CIA agents arguing that they were just following orders issued by the upper echelon of the Bush administration; then you have to go after the legal architects of the memos, and even further up the Bush administration's "food chain" to whomever gave the instructions to draft the documents in question. This lack of legal logic is troubling from someone as smart as Obama; especially considering that he has a background in constitutional law.
Second, it is a huge political mistake. The intelligence hard liners are up in arms that the memos were released by the Obama administration. On the left, the liberals & libertarians are even more critical over Obama's decision not to prosecute either the CIA operatives or the Bush administration itself. When the torture memos were released last week Obama said:"We have been through a dark and painful chapter of our history". This is completely accurate, but what doesn't make any sense is to basically sweep everything under the rug of history just for the sake of moving on. Today, Rahm Emmanuel was spinning Obama's decision on Sunday's political talk shows circuit by explaining again that we need to turn the page. We need to do the complete opposite to prevent anything like that to ever happen again under any circumstances.
Third, it is a big International " faux pas". The obama administration was making a lot of progress in their handling of foreign relations. Not prosecuting the CIA agents was strongly criticized by a top UN official. He has charged that " Obama violated international law with his decision not to prosecute CIA agents who tortured detainees". It is sending the wrong message all across the world, as if America is above international laws.
The case of President Obama refusing to prosecute the CIA agents for torture is drastically different in appearance but has, as a matter of fact, quite a lot of political similarities.
There is a lack of logic to it from a legal stand point, and further it is a political disaster in the making.
First, if you are not going to prosecute the CIA agents arguing that they were just following orders issued by the upper echelon of the Bush administration; then you have to go after the legal architects of the memos, and even further up the Bush administration's "food chain" to whomever gave the instructions to draft the documents in question. This lack of legal logic is troubling from someone as smart as Obama; especially considering that he has a background in constitutional law.
Second, it is a huge political mistake. The intelligence hard liners are up in arms that the memos were released by the Obama administration. On the left, the liberals & libertarians are even more critical over Obama's decision not to prosecute either the CIA operatives or the Bush administration itself. When the torture memos were released last week Obama said:"We have been through a dark and painful chapter of our history". This is completely accurate, but what doesn't make any sense is to basically sweep everything under the rug of history just for the sake of moving on. Today, Rahm Emmanuel was spinning Obama's decision on Sunday's political talk shows circuit by explaining again that we need to turn the page. We need to do the complete opposite to prevent anything like that to ever happen again under any circumstances.
Third, it is a big International " faux pas". The obama administration was making a lot of progress in their handling of foreign relations. Not prosecuting the CIA agents was strongly criticized by a top UN official. He has charged that " Obama violated international law with his decision not to prosecute CIA agents who tortured detainees". It is sending the wrong message all across the world, as if America is above international laws.
Labels:
cia,
napoleon,
obama,
political opinion,
torture,
written by Gilbert Mercier
Sunday, March 15, 2009
Red Cross Described Torture at CIA Jails.
The International Committee of the Red Cross concluded in a secret report that the Bush administration's treatment of al-Qaeda captives 'constituted torture,' a finding that strongly implied that CIA interrogation methods violated international law, according to newly published excerpts from the...
read more | digg story
read more | digg story
Labels:
cia,
red cross,
top page digg,
torture,
written by Gilbert Mercier
Tuesday, August 5, 2008
In 'Way Of The World,' Fabricating A Case For War
In The Way of the World: A Story of Truth And Hope In An Age of Extremism, author Ron Suskind alleges that the Bush administration knew Iraq had no weapons of mass destruction, and eventually fabricated intelligence assets to support its case for war. The White House and the CIA deny his claims.
read more digg story
read more digg story
Labels:
bush administration,
cia,
iraq war,
mercier,
npr,
ron suskind,
wmd
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
